flarenut (flarenut) wrote,

  • Mood:


In the parking lot of the local food co-op, as I was going there with B this afternoon, there was a lady handing out anti-vaccination leaflets (under the disigenuous heading of "know your rights"), and of course she approached us. I said no thanks, and that I was absolutely opposed to her position. She asked why, and I told her that when enough people stopped vaccinating their kids you lost herd immunity, and children died. She offered me a pamphlet purporting to explain why herd immunity is bunk, and I declined and took B into the store to get some peanut butter.

The experience shook me, largely because of how angry I found myself becoming. Some of that anger was because of the implied challenge to my knowledge (well, gee, I've only been reading studies for 30 years) but a large chunk of it was what I can most accurately describe as parental rage. Part of me wanted to say "You may not know it, but you want my son to be dead, and that is not OK." C's prematurity meant that he had a completely screwed-up immune system (not to mention lung damage) as a toddler; he's exactly the kind of kid who would be expected to die in an outbreak of any of the standard preventable childhood diseases. I care somewhat when people are misguided enough to put their own kids at risk, but way more when they're putting mine at risk too.

And that was even before I got (in my esprit d'escalier while cruising the vegetable department) into the part about anti-vaxers being a bunch of irresponsible freeloaders who get to take advantage of everyone else's socially-minded behavior while avoiding any perceived risks for themselves. This is something that just pisses me off.

I don't know. Maybe I should have handled things differently. Just politely accepted a leaflet and moved on. Or said "no thanks". Or said, "Why would anyone possibly want to pass up a chance to protect their child's life and the lives of other children?" or "You know that the whole autism thing was started by a guy who was paid to fabricate data by an ambulance-chasing law firm, don't you?"

Tags: politeness, science, tlb

  • Is there any way to make the logistics of camping not suck?

    As I write this the tent parts are drying in the sun, and I'm drinking iced coffee with extra milk. The other night was C's school's fall campout.…

  • Peter, Pan Jr

    Took B to see the local musical theatre camp's production of Peter Pan (C is en route to visit his grandmother -- first flight as an unaccompanied…

  • Tonight I learned

    that if you ask the debian installer to keep the data you have on a partition that you then want mounted, it will helpfully protect every gigabyte of…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 1 comment