flarenut (flarenut) wrote,
flarenut
flarenut

Pierre Menard, author of The Leavenworth Case

Gutenberg's detective section is most politely described as uneven.

I was on tenterhooks reading this particular piece of shite, because I just couldn't believe the plot would be so convolutedly stupid, that so many people would give vent to so much purple, that the narrator would be such a nattering popinjay.

Then I considered that if such passages were written today they would be a tour de force of irony and social commentary. Still shite, but masterful shite. What writer today could take seriously the idea of a narrator driven almost entirely by chivalry, botching clue after clue through delicacy of feeling? How could there be anything but wheels within wheels in a murder motive depending on ethnic prejudice and Hinckley-level stalker love? What if the whole lack of coherent sense were really a brilliant nihilistic sendup?

Mais non.

Tags: books
Subscribe

  • Winter Driving

    On an unplowed highway. At 417 in the morning. With just enough traffic that you can't go slowly, but not enough so you can deduce road conditions…

  • Apple doesn't want me as a customer any more

    No, really. I don't spend enough on i-devices, I use them in unprofitable ways, I'm getting too old. Which is fine if they want to focus their…

  • Maybe they just lied

    Years and years and years ago, I got a shuttle xpc, and it didn't work worth a damn. Wouldn't install anything till I just took a working disk out of…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 0 comments